C Papanikolaou, K Fortounis, S Ainalis, K Biba, A Papanikolaou, G Hatzitheoxaris
ascites, hydrothorax, meigs syndrome, pelvicovarian tumors, pseudo-meigs syndrome
C Papanikolaou, K Fortounis, S Ainalis, K Biba, A Papanikolaou, G Hatzitheoxaris. Pseudo-Meigs Syndrome: A Case Report. The Internet Journal of Pathology. 2004 Volume 4 Number 2.
Meigs syndrome is defined as the co-existence of bening ovarian fibroma, hydrothorax and ascites. On the contrary, Pseudo-Meigs syndrome is characterized by the co-existence of hydrothorax, ascites and other ovarian- usually malignant-or pelvic tumors.
The case herein presented concerns a 54 year old postmenopausal woman with recurrent, since 1 year, perineal phlegmon and currently established respiratory distress. Her clinical and radiological examination revealed a massive right pleural effusion, mild ascites and a large heterogeneous, with solid and cystic components, pelvic tumor, measured 15x15cm, causing pressure to the bladder. After a preoperative relieving paracentesis and drainage of the pleural effusion-with negative for malignant cells cytologic examination, the patient underwent an exploratory laparotomy with excision of both the tumor and the righ ovary. The tumor was diagnosed histologically as an ovarian well differentiated endometrioid carcinoma. The immediate postoperative resolution of hydrothorax and ascites confirmed the diagnosis of pseudo-Meigs syndrome. The patient followed chemotherapy and remains in good condition 18 months after surgery, without any indication of metastatic disease.
The co-existence of pelvic tumor, hydrothorax and ascites has been known since the late 19th century. The features of the disease were described by Meigs and Cass in 1937. In the same year Roads named it “Meigs syndrome”. Today, Meigs syndrome is defined as the co-existence of bening ovarian fibroma, hydrothorax and ascites. On the contrary, Pseudo-Meigs syndrome is characterized by the co-existence of hydrothorax, ascites and other ovarian- usually malignant-or pelvic tumors. Both these syndromes should be considered in otherwise healthy postmenopausal women, who present with either new or recurrent hydrothorax and ascites. The preoperative differential diagnosis between them is useless, since the surgical resection of the tumor is the only therapeutic choice, resulting to the resolution of fluid accumulations in both situations1.
A 54 year old postmenopausal woman admitted in our Clinic because of recurrent, since 1 year, perineal phlegmon and currently established respiratory distress.
The clinical examination revealed sinus tachycardia, absence of breath sounds at the auscultation of the right hemithorax, perineal redness and a palpable mass of the lower abdomen. A massive right pleural effusion was found at chest x-ray (Fig. 1).
Computed tomography of the abdomen demonstrated mild ascites and a large heterogeneous, with solid and cystic components, pelvic tumor, measured 15x15cm, causing pressure to the bladder (Fig. 2A, B).
These findings were combined with leycocytosis (WBC: 23100/mm3, NE: 87,9%, LY: 7,7%, MO: 3,6%, BA: 0,8%), hyperkalemia (K: 5,9 meq/L) and elevation of tumour markers CEA (5,7ng/ml, NR: <3), CA 19-9 (500U/ml, NR: 0-37) and CA 125 (386,8 U/ml, NR: 0-35).
A preoperative paracentesis and drainage of pleural effusion was necessary to relieve the patient's dyspneic symptomatology. The cytologic examination of the fluid was negative for malignant cells.
The patient underwent an exploratory laparotomy with excision of both the tumor and the righ ovary. The tumor was diagnosed histologically as an ovarian well differentiated endometrioid carcinoma (Fig. 3).
The immediate postoperative resolution of hydrothorax and ascites confirmed the diagnosis of pseudo-Meigs syndrome (Fig.4).
The patient followed chemotherapy and remains in good condition 18 months after surgery, without any indication of metastatic disease.
The pseudo-Meigs syndrome can be combined with either benign or malignant neoplasms (Tabl.1).
The etiology of the fluid accumulations remains unclear, although it appears to be related to lymphatic obstruction. The most likely pathogenesis of peritoneal and pleural effusions ascribes filtration of interstitial fluid in the peritoneum through the tumor capsule, and diffusion to the pleural space, usually at the right side, through diaphragmatic lymphatic vessels and apertures, as well as through intercellular gaps and small areas where muscular tissue of the diaphragm is replaced by areolar tissue2, 3.
The majority of ovarian tumors, associated with hydrothorax and ascites, have a diameter of more than 6cm. The entity of effusions can be moderate or massive. The effusions generally derive from a transudative process, but can occasionally contain blood cells. Their connection with the pelvic tumor is demonstrated by their regression after neoplasm removal.
The pseudo-Meigs syndrome is clinically important because it resembles metastatic pelvic cancer. Especially in patients with malignant ovarian tumors, cytologic examination of the body cavity effusions is essential to differentiate between reactive process and metastatic tumor spread4. While detection of malignant cells is a marker of metastatic disease and a sign of bad prognosis, benign effusions of pseudo-Meigs syndrome affect neither disease stage nor the patient's prognosis. Determination of the presence or absence of tumor spread is based primarily on cellular morphology study, but if distinction between reactive mesothial and cancer cells is difficult, immunocytochemistry may be necessary.
At this point, must be underlined that an ovarian mass combined with pleural and peritoneal effusions not always represents an advanced malignancy, even with elevation of CA 125 value5, 6. There are some benign pelvic lesions causing pseudo-Meigs syndrome, which are associated with elevated levels of this tumor marker, such as struma ovarii, ovarian cystadenomas, uterine leiomyomas and broad ligament leiomyomas3, 7,8,9,10,11,12,13. CA 125 levels decline to the normal range after tumor resection.
In the literature, are reported unique, of special interest, cases of pseudo-Meigs syndrome caused by rare pathological conditions (Tabl.2).
There also reported 6 cases of pseudo-Meigs syndrome caused by secondary ovarian tumors from gastrointestinal cancers21. The primary site was the colon or rectum in 5 and the stomach in 1. Two cases were due to Krukenberg tumors. Three patients with documented outcomes were alive 108, 52 and 12 months after resections, demonstrating that in these cases resection provide long-term palliation.
There is an interesting current study that sets the question whether common uterine leiomyomas and uterine leiomyomas causing pseudo-Meigs syndrome are cytogenetically related or whether functionally differences in tumour phenotype, and supports a model in which accumulation of the independent mutations- a classical structural rearrangement involving HMGA2 and RAD51L1, in combination with a loss of the second RAD51L1 allele-might play a major role in the development of pseudo-Meigs syndrome22.
Pseudo-Meigs syndrome should be considered as a rare differential diagnosis for pleural and ascites effusions. Patients with pseudo-Meigs syndrome may present a diagnostic problem as they masquerade as carcinoma with malignant effusions. Thus they should always undergone exploratory laparotomy. Surgical therapy has a very important role for the complete remission of the disease in cases of benign tumors, and for the remission of pleural and ascites effusions in cases of malignant tumors.
Papanikolaou Ch. 28 Sokratous street 55134 Thessaloniki, Greece Tel. 0030 2310 433906 0030 2310 892362 e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org