ISPUB.com / IJFS/3/1/8463
  • Author/Editor Login
  • Registration
  • Facebook
  • Google Plus

ISPUB.com

Internet
Scientific
Publications

  • Home
  • Journals
  • Latest Articles
  • Disclaimers
  • Article Submissions
  • Contact
  • Help
  • The Internet Journal of Forensic Science
  • Volume 3
  • Number 1

Original Article

Accuracy Of Balwant Rai Equations In Age Determinant From Osteons An Age

B Rai, N Sahni, S Anand, S Dhattarwal, D Bhardwaj, V Kangra, P Chadha

Keywords

age, balwant rai equation, compact bone, mandible, osteons

Citation

B Rai, N Sahni, S Anand, S Dhattarwal, D Bhardwaj, V Kangra, P Chadha. Accuracy Of Balwant Rai Equations In Age Determinant From Osteons An Age. The Internet Journal of Forensic Science. 2007 Volume 3 Number 1.

Abstract

A histological study was conducted on 82 subjects of both sexes (Male 41 Female 41) from the compact portion of mandible to determine age by Balwant Rai Equation. In majority of the cases it was observed that the low (2-6 years) as compared to actual age.

 

Introduction

Identification and determination of unknown human skeletal remains has been one of the most challenging tasks for forensic medico-legal. Age is an extremely vital parameter in personal identity of living subjects as well as skeletonised dead bodies. Determination of age from skeletal remains has been studied and analysed by many workers. 1,2,3,4,5,6 The determination of age at time of death from histology of compact bone was has been studied by researchers. It is not only possible to differentiate between human and non-human bone fragments. (Schranz, 1954) but also the age of the individual bone. 7 The most effective study of several other studies on bone histology and age related charges was carried out by Kerely (1965 and 1969), 8,9,10,11 who developed a method of age determination based on microscopic analysis of the cortex of the long bones.

Singh and Gung (1970) studied bone section for various parameters including osteons. 8 It was observed that the number of osteons increased with age. Present study was done for determination of age of the individual at death of both sexes from the compact portion of mandible on histological observation by Balwant Rai.

Material and Method

This study was done on the compact portion of mandible, collected from 41 males and 41 females of know age, brought for postmortem examination at Post Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Rohtak. Bone samples from adult persons devoid of any bone anomalies were studied.

In the present study slides from bone samples were prepared by under calcified method. Initially the bone samples were boiled in soap solution (Nirma Soap) for five hours to remove organic material. After washing, they were suspended over cholorform for 50 hours to remove fats. Each section was cut with Jeweller's saw into several sections. These sections were hand grinded untill they become transparent. Transparent sections were fixed on slides with the help of D.P.X. monutant.

In each section the number of osteons, consisting of complete haverian system were counted in four fields, taking the average osteons that were obliquely cut were included only if the complete haverian canal was seen.

Observations

Following Balwant Rai equation was applied after for age determination.

Figure 1
Table 1: mean± sd of actual age and estimated age in various group.

Age determination by Balwant Rai equation is less as compared to actual (2-6 years).

Discussion

Traditional method of estimation of age depends upon gross morphologic criteria which has been useful, but age limited in application. 5 Quantitative histology on the other hand permits objectivity and resulting data are amendable to statistical analysis. The value of histological method are further significant because of their limited demand of amount of material resulted for estimation.

In present study that number of osteons and average number of lamellae per osteon increased with age but heversian canal diameter decreased with age and studied by Singh and Gunberg (1970). 8 In present study notical, variable and diameter of secondary osteons as by William et al (1995) 9 in adult compact bone.

Dr. S.Lal et al (2004)5 had noticed different size and shape of secondary osteons at 18 to 55 years of age, where as after 55 years of age the secondary osteons appeared more or less uniform while in present study size and shape of secondary osteon is variable and not uniform at age groups. Also there was a gradual increase in number of osteons with age. It was 12 osteons per field at about 20 years, 15 obsteons at 23 years, 30 osteons at 35 years and 50 osteons at 58 years of age. While in tibia (S.Lal et al, 2004) osteons was approximately 15 osteons per field at about 15 years, 35 osteons at 40 years and 47 osteons at 65 years of age.

The derive equation arrived at shows the difference approximately of 2 to 6 years between the actual and estimated age.

Conclusion

It has been reported that estimation of age by Balwant Rai equation although it may be useful in age determination as a assisting tool for forensic.

Correspondence to

Balwant Rai
S/o Sh. Ram Swaroop
Village Bhangu,
District Sirsa,
Post Office Sahuwala First
Haryana (INDIA)
Mobile 0091-9812185855

References

1. Rai B, Anand SC, Dhattarwal SK. Osteons as an age determinant. Medicolegal Update. 2005; 4 (3): 99-100.
2. Karley ER. The microscopic determination of age in human bone. Am J Phy Anthrop. 1965; 23 : 149-163.
3. Chatterji S and Jaffrey JW. Changes in structure of human bone with age. Nature, 1968; 290 : 482.
4. Ahlquist J and Damsten O. "A modification of Kerlay's method for the microscopic determination of age in human bones" Forensic Sci. 1969; 14 : 205-217.
5. Iwamoto S, Oomuki E and Kanchi M. A study on age related changes of compact bone and age estimation as the femur bone. Med J Kinki Univ (Japan) 1978; 3 : 223-232.
6. Lal S. et al. Histological estimation of age from osteons. Medico legal update. April-June 2004 Vol 4 No. 2, 67-68.
7. Schranz D. Age determination from the internal structure of humerus. Am J Phy Anthrop, 1954; 17 : 273-277.
8. Karley ER and Vbelakar DH. Revision in the microscopic method of estimation age at death in human cortical bone, Am J Phy Anthrop. 1978 48 : 545-546.
9. Singh IJ and Gunberg DL. Estimation of age at death in human males from quantitative histology of bone fragments. Am J Phy Anthrop, 1970; 33 : 373-382.
10. William et al. Bone as tissue in Grey's Anatomy, 38th Edition, ELBS with Churchill Livingstone, pp. 452-468.
11. Karley ER. Age determination of bone fragments, J For Sci 1969;14 : 59-67.

Author Information

Balwant Rai
Ex-Resident, Govt. Dental College, Pt. B.D. Sharma PGIMS

Neeraj Sahni, M.Sc. (Oral Medicine)
Eastman Dental Institute London (UK)

S.C. Anand
Principal, Deptt. of Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery, Govt. Dental College, Pt. B.D. Sharma PGIMS

S.K. Dhattarwal
Associate Professor, Dept. of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology, Pt. B.D. Sharma PGIMS

D.N. Bhardwaj
Additional Professor, Dept. of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences

Vinod K. Kangra
PG Student, Dept. of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology, Pt. B.D. Sharma PGIMS

Puja Chadha, BDS

Download PDF

Your free access to ISPUB is funded by the following advertisements:

 

BACK TO TOP
  • Facebook
  • Google Plus

© 2013 Internet Scientific Publications, LLC. All rights reserved.    UBM Medica Network Privacy Policy