The Diagnostic Value Of The "Air Bubble Sign" In Complicated Pulmonary Hydatid Cysts
G Yuncu, S Örs Kaya, S Sevinc, N Karabulut, H Alper
ct, hydatid disease, lung-air bubble
G Yuncu, S Örs Kaya, S Sevinc, N Karabulut, H Alper. The Diagnostic Value Of The "Air Bubble Sign" In Complicated Pulmonary Hydatid Cysts. The Internet Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery. 2004 Volume 7 Number 2.
The aim of this study was to investigate the utility of the "air bubble sign" in infected hydatid cysts. We reviewed the computed tomography findings in 35 patients with surgically proven infected hydatid cysts, of whom 13 cases did not have correct diagnosis preoperatively. We also assessed the CT findings in a randomly chosen 30 patients with various benign and malignant pulmonary diseases. We found the air bubble sign to be present in overall 30 of 35 cases (sensitivity of 85.7%) with infected hydatid cysts and in one of the randomly chosen 30 cases in the control group with various lung diseases (specificity of 96.6%). High accuracy rate of air bubble sign may help the correct diagnosis of complicated hydatid cysts in equivocal cases and preclude unnecessary investigations and invasive diagnostic procedures.
Hydatid disease is prevalent and widespread in most sheep and cattle raising countries throughout the world. Pulmonary hydatid cyst is one of the most common diseases seen in thoracic surgical centers in Turkey with an incidence of 20 per 1.000.000 . Pulmonary involvement occurs in approximately 15% of cases being the second most frequent site after liver . A variety of signs denoting different appearances of the hydatid cysts have been described on chest radiographs and CT. In uncomplicated hydatid cysts, radiologic diagnosis is relatively easy. CT provides further information in equivocal cases by revealing the fluid density of an intact cyst and the air-fluid density of a ruptured cyst. However, infection of the cyst may increase the attenuation values and a produce a solid appearance, which may hamper the correct diagnosis. Such a complicated cyst, in the absence of positive history, serologic tests and other radiologic signs, may simulate a malignant tumour, tuberculosis, abscess and other infected cystic lesions of the lung. The “air bubble sign” was described in complicated cysts and reported to be an important clue in the differentiation of hydatid cysts from other disease processes . This study aimed to assess the diagnostic value of the air bubble sign in the diagnosis of ruptured pulmonary hydatid disease.
Material And Methods
In the past five years, 35 consecutive patients (17 males, 18 females) who underwent surgical treatment for ruptured and infected hydatid cysts were included in the study. The patients ranged in age from 14-69 years (mean, 36.2 years). All patients had preoperative CT examinations which were reported as solid lesions measuring >20 HU in density. The correct preoperative diagnosis was not established in 13 cases based on radiologic and serologic findings. The control group consisted of 30 cases (16 males, 14 females; mean age 52 years, range 23-69 years) with pathologically proven 20 malignant (13 squamous cell carcinoma, four adenocarcinoma, one large cell carcinoma and two small cell carcinoma) and 10 benign (four tuberculosis, four pneumonia, one pulmonary embolism and one lung abscess) pulmonary diseases which may radiologically simulate complicated hydatid cysts. In all patients in the study and control groups, final histopathological diagnoses were available.
CT examinations of both groups were re-evaluated in retrospect and reported by the two radiologists, first without taking account of, then considering the air bubble sign. The final decision was established by consensus. Data were statistically evaluated with the chi-square test using Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS , 11.0, Chicago, I11).
Twenty-one cysts (60%) were located in the right lung (10 in upper lobe; four in middle lobe; seven in lower lobe) and 14 cysts (40%) occurred in the left lung (five in upper lobe; nine in lower lobe). Evaluation of the CT examinations in 35 complicated hydatid cysts according to the classical CT signs, ignoring the air bubble sign, led to the diagnosis of complicated hydatid cyst in 18 (51.1%), malignant lung tumour in nine (25.7%), infectious processes (pneumonia and abscesses) in five (14.2%) and tuberculoma or cavitary tuberculosis in three patients (8.5%). In four of the 17 patients otherwise diagnosed, serologic tests and bronchoscopy led to the correct diagnosis of hydatid disease leading to the total correct diagnosis in 22 patients (62.8%). When the air bubble sign was taken into an account, it was positive in 30 of 35 cases, increasing the sensitivity to 85.7% (Figs.1,2). In three of five cases in which the air bubble sign was absent correct clinical diagnosis of ruptured, infected hydatid cysts were already established by clinical and other laboratory evaluation. Therefore complementary use of the air bubble sign, and laboratory tests increased correct diagnosis
from 62.8 % to 94.3%.
The air bubble sign was present in none of the 20 tumour patients, and in only one of the benign control cases (specificity 96,6%). The total accuracy of the air bubble sign was 90.7%. Correct diagnosis of ruptured, infected, solid hydatid cysts using air bubble sign was significantly higher than diagnosis with classical CT signs (p <0.01).
Hydatid disease represents the larval form of the canine intestinal tapeworm
Solid appearances on CT scan, precluding the correct differentiation between hydatid disease and malignant tumour, lead to further, more invasive and time consuming diagnostic attempts such as bronchoscopy, transthoracic needle aspiration, abdominal and cranial CT and scintigraphic examinations. A number of radiologic signs of the ruptured hydatid cysts have been described on chest radiographs and on CT due to separated membranes. These include the “crescent”, “water –lily”, “ daughter cysts”, “double arch”, “ring within a ring”, “serpent” or “snake” and “spin or whirl” signs [7,8]. However, Köktürk et al reported that radiologic diagnosis of ruptured hydatid cysts with classical CT signs was possible in only 38 of 65 (58.5 %) patients . In their series, 27 of 65 (41.5%) patients were misdiagnosed as bronchial carcinoma or lung abscesses. They reported significantly higher accuracy rate with air bubble sign. The air bubble sign has also been described as a specific sign in complicated hydatid cysts by Kervancioglu et al .
The mechanism of air bubble production is the dissection of air between the pericyst and parasitic membrane due to rupture or erosion of a bronchiole [2,8]. Air bubble sign is best demonstrated in mediastinal window settings as single or multiple small, rounded radiolucent areas with very sharp margins within solid media or pericystic areas. They should not, however, be mistaken as cavitations or pseudocavitations.
In a series of 34 patients with surgically proven hydatid cysts, Tör et al reported the air bubble sign to be present in 56% of 18 patients in whom the initial radiologic impression was hydatid cyst and 44% of 16 patients in whom the initial radiologic impression was not hydatid cyst . Köktürk et al reported 83% sensitivity and 94.5% specificity with air bubble sign in the diagnosis of ruptured cysts . In our series, only 51% of cases was correct diagnosis possible based on classical CT findings ignoring the air bubble sign. When combined with the broncoscopic and serologic findings sensitivity increased to 63%. However, the use of air bubble sign significantly increased the sensitivity to 86% when used alone, and 94% when combined with the serologic and endoscopic findings.
In conclusion, the air bubble sign is proved to be a reliable and reproducible finding in complicated hydatid cysts. The familiarity of radiologists with this sign is essential in establishing the correct diagnosis in equivocal cases and precluding unnecessary investigations and invasive diagnostic procedures, particularly in those countries where the disease is endemic.
Dr.Seyda Ors KAYA Address: Pamukkale Üniversitesi Mavi Hastane Göğüs Cerrahisi AD Kinikli Denizli,Turkey Tel: +902582120718 e-mail: email@example.com Fax:+90 258 21320 16