S Gulati, Anshu, R Wadhera, A Deeo
ethmoidal polyps, functional endoscopic sinus surgery
S Gulati, Anshu, R Wadhera, A Deeo. Efficacy of Functional Endoscopic Sinus Surgery in the treatment of Ethmoidal polyps. The Internet Journal of Otorhinolaryngology. 2006 Volume 7 Number 1.
The efficacy of sinus surgery for treatment of ethmoidal polyps continues to be an issue of debate among otolaryngologists. A study was undertaken to assess the efficacy of Functional Endoscopic Sinus Surgery (FESS) in treatment of ethmoidal polyps. Thirty patients of either sex above 16 years of age, suffering from ethmoidal polyps were included in the study. The patients were discharged a day after surgery and were called for endoscopic examination during subsequent follow up. Final results were recorded 3 months after the operative procedure. The results suggest that FESS is highly effective for treatment of ethmoidal polyps with the recurrence rate being as low as 10% and with no major complication.
Nasal polyps remain a significant challenge to the treating physician. The treatment modalities of nasal polyps encompass both medical and surgical modalities following the assessment of the patient. Surgical treatment comprises of polypectomy which has a high recurrence rate, intranasal ethmoidectomy – a blind procedure and external ethmoidectomy with its inherent complication of external scar. All these shortcomings are overcome by FESS, which is fast becoming the surgical treatment of choice for nasal polyp disease. The first attempt at nasal and sinus endoscopy was performed by Hirschmann in 1901 using modified cystoscope. Since then, many advances have been made in the field of endoscopic sinus surgery.1
In the early 1970s, Messerklinger theory that the anatomical variations of the lateral nasal wall could cause obstruction of both drainage and ventilation of the sinuses, initiated the development of a functionally oriented surgical approach. 2,3 The functional endoscopic sinus surgery technique provides a tool by which the clinician can accurately diagnose, meticulously and atraumatically perform surgery and precisely provide post-operative care and follow up for nasal polyp diseases. The present study was undertaken to evaluate the efficacy of functional endoscopic sinus surgery in the treatment of ethmoidal polyps.
Materials And Methods
The present study was conducted in the Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Pt. B. D. Sharma Post Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Rohtak. Thirty patients of either sex above 16 years of age, suffering from ethmoidal polyps were included in the study. Patients having antrochoanal polyp, marked deviated nasal septum, and nasal or antral growth were excluded from the study.
Initial patient work-up included detailed history taking about the symptoms and their duration. Thereafter, detailed examination including anterior rhinoscopy, posterior rhinoscopy, throat and ear examination was done. All patients were given medical treatment for two weeks in the form of broad-spectrum antibiotics, antihistaminics and local or systemic decongestants. The patients were then subjected to computed tomography scan of paranasal sinuses- both axial and coronal views. Patients were taken up for the surgery under local anaesthesia after the routine investigations like complete haemogram, urine albumin and sugar and other relevant investigations.
The extent of surgery was decided based on the findings in pre-operative CT scan of paranasal sinuses. Anterior ethmoidectomy, posterior ethmoidectomy, middle meatus antrostomy and clearance of frontal recess were performed in all the patients. Sphenoid sinus ostium was widened only if CT scan showed evidence of its involvement. Along with this any significant anatomical abnormality was also noted and taken care of during surgery. At the time of discharge from the hospital, the patients were given systemic antibiotic for 10 days along with decongestant drops. Steroid nasal spray was advised in all cases. Alkaline nasal douching was also advised. Patients were advised follow-up after one week, six weeks and three months.
The findings in 30 cases of bilateral ethmoidal polyps undergoing FESS were recorded. It was observed that the age of patients in the study ranged from 17-65 years with the most common age affected being 30-39 years (36.7%) followed by 40-49 years (23.3%). The males were more commonly affected than females, the ratio being 2.7:1.
Nasal obstruction was the most common symptom present in 25patients followed by nasal discharge in 23, recurrent attacks of common cold in 22, post nasal discharge and sneezing in 20 each, headache in 18 and anosmia and facial pain in 10 and 5 patients respectively. Preoperative CT scan findings of the patients are summarized in Table (1).The CT scan in 2 patients showed destruction of wall of sinuses along with areas of hyperdensities admixed with mucosal hypertrophy pointing towards fungal infection.
Intra operative findings were also recorded. Bilateral polypoidal mucosa in anterior ethmoidal cells was found in all 30 patients. Posterior ethmoidal air cells were involved in 23 subjects bilaterally and in 3 subjects unilaterally. Mucoid discharge in maxillary antrum was seen in 14 patients, pus in 4 patients, polyps and hypertrophic mucosa in 4 patients each. Sphenoid involvement in the form of polypoidal mucosa was seen in 4 patients bilaterally and in 2 patients unilaterally. Cheesy material along with polyps which on histopathological examination indicated aspergillosis was found in 2 patients. Anatomical variations in the form of accessory ostium (7patients), bilateral concha bullosa (6 patients), bilateral paradoxical middle turbinate (5 patients) and polypoidal degeneration of both middle turbinates (5 cases) were noted. Relief in symptoms after surgery and endoscopic findings on follow up are summarized in Table II and III respectively. The recurrence of polyps was seen in 3 cases who had stopped using the steroid nasal spray. One patient presented with secondary hemorrhage ten days after surgery, which was controlled with nasal packing. No other major or minor complication was seen.
The results of 30 patients of bilateral ethmoidal polyps undergoing FESS were analysed. The final follow up was done after three months of surgery.
Revision surgery was undertaken in three cases because of recurrence of the polyps. These patients had stopped using steroid nasal spray. Patients who were using steroid nasal spray regularly did not have recurrence of polyps. Patients having fungal infection were given cap Itraconazole 200 mg BD for 3 months along with steroid nasal spray and they were completely asymptomatic at subsequent follow up.
These findings are in concurrence with the findings of other studies. Levine in his study on 250 patients found success rate of functional endoscopic sinus surgery to be 89.7% for relief of sinonasal polyposis.4 Danielson5 reported a success rate of 90%, while both Smith6 and Rice7 quoted 88% for the same.
As in our study, success rate was 90% and only 10% patients needed revision surgery, it may be concluded that functional endoscopic sinus surgery is highly effective as a treatment for ethmoidal polyps.
Dr. Anshu, H.No. 99, Sector- 14, Rohtak-124001. (Haryana) INDIA. E-mail ID: email@example.com Phone no: 09315328727