Pattern Of Morbidity And Health Seeking Behavior In A Slum Area Of Ahmedabad City in India
T Puwar, B Kumpavat, K Trivedi
Keywords
health seeking behaviour, morbidity, urban slums
Citation
T Puwar, B Kumpavat, K Trivedi. Pattern Of Morbidity And Health Seeking Behavior In A Slum Area Of Ahmedabad City in India. The Internet Journal of Health. 2008 Volume 9 Number 2.
Abstract
Introduction
Information on the existing morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour is essential to provide need-based health care delivery to any population. This information is rarely available. Mainly hospital data are available for morbidity pattern. Community based study can only reflect the true picture of morbidity pattern in given community and what are their preferences in seeking health.
Episodes of illnesses are reported to be higher for poor people due to their living conditions and nutritional status. The high incidence of morbidity cuts their household budget both ways i.e. not only they have to spend large amount of resources on medical care but are also unable to earn during this period. One possible consequences of this could be pushing these families into a zone of permanent poverty1.
It is widely known that in India compared to the public sector, the private sector is predominant in its share of qualified practitioners as well hospitals. An estimated 85% of doctors and 65% of hospitals operate in the private sector2. The private sector provides 79 percent of outpatient care for those below the poverty line, much of which is of low quality and provided by untrained practitioners.
27.78% of India’s population live in urban areas. Out of which 40,297,341 people lives in slum areas across 607 towns of the country. In Gujarat State about 12% population lives in slum area3, 4. Till now not much is known about health seeking behaviour and morbidity patterns of urban slums. With above information the study was aimed to know the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour in a slum area of city.
Methodology
Study Material and Method
A pre-designed, pre-tested proforma were used for family study and collecting information regarding morbidity and health seeking behaviour in household survey.
1. Questionnaire for person hospitalized during last one year (From Feb. 2001 to January 2002)
2. Questionnaire for illnesses treated without hospitalization and untreated illnesses (recall period one week)
3. Questionnaire for chronic illnesses (Includes newly diagnosed in 3 months and also suffering from illness since long)
4. Questionnaire for immunization
5. Questionnaire for Maternal Health
Results and Discussion
Socio-Demographic profile
Total population covered under the study was 685 persons. Out of which 316 (46%) were females and 369(54%) were males. About 57% of population was in reproductive age group. About 14% of population was under 6 years of age. Overall literacy rate was 76.4%. The female literacy rate was 62.9% and male literacy rate was 88.7%
Mainly the Casual daily waged labourers inhabited slum
61.6% houses were not having adequate ventilation and 65.2% houses were not having adequate light. 7.1% houses were devoid of electricity connection. 46% houses had their own toilets and the rest use municipal common toilets. All houses were connected with municipal underground sewerage line. Only 58% of houses had closed bathing facility, rest used open space for bathing. This is important aspect as it affects the personal hygiene especially of females.
Morbidity pattern of Households
Details of illness episodes for each of the family members were collected using the different recall periods. The recall period for Acute Illnesses treated without hospitalization (as out patient) was 15 days, for hospitalization, chronic illnesses and maternity it was one-year period.
It gives the prevalence of morbidity for a selected community.
Acute illnesses: (Treated as out patient or not treated)
There were total 78 episodes of acute illnesses reported in the study area. Out of which 17.9% episodes were not treated. No. of episodes were more in females (67%) than in males. This difference is statistically significant (chi-square value – 12.59 p< 0.001). As per diagnosis 45.3% of episodes were of Cough (Respiratory Tract Infection), followed by 23.4% episodes were of Fever and 7.8% episodes were of other communicable diseases like Measles, Chicken pox and typhoid. The total burden of communicable diseases was found to be 76.6% (total 49 episodes) on the community.
Acute illnesses: (Treated as Hospitalization)
The average age of patients hospitalized was 26.6 years. The average duration of stay for hospitalization was 9.3 days. 33.3% episodes of hospitalization were due to surgical cause, followed by 25.9% for infectious diseases like Hepatitis and Typhoid. 18.5% cases were of Malaria and 7.4% cases were of accidents or injuries.70.4% patients had case papers while only 29.6% of them had bills. 96.3% patients were admitted in general wards.
Chronic Illnesses:
For chronic illnesses all episodes observed during survey was taken in the study. The prevalence of chronic morbidity per 1000 person was 45.2 (53.8 for Females & 38.0 for Males). The prevalence per 1000 persons in age above 65 was 200 and in age group 46-64 it was 78.6. Which shows higher prevalence in that age group. The average age was 41.3 years.
Prevalence of Hypertension per 1000 person was 10.2 and of Tuberculosis was 7.2 per 1000 persons. 9.9% cases were of Thyroid disorders, 9.9% of Psychiatric illnesses, 6.6% cases were of Rheumatic Heart Diseases and 3.3% cases were of Coronary Heart Disease.
Average duration of treatment was 6 years. For Tuberculosis it was 7 months and for Hypertension it was 45 months.
Health Seeking Behaviour for different morbidities:
It is evident from the table-III that community depends heavily upon private practitioner for the acute illnesses treated as out patient. It was the found that no male sufferer has gone to public facility for treatment of acute illnesses treated as out patient. People also avoided going to Public facility because of long queue and loss of time due to the same.
The average duration of acute illness episodes treated as out patient can be considered as an indicator of the seriousness of illness. However, a prompt treatment can moderate the duration. In this study average duration of illness was 3 days. 80% of patients have sought treatment without delay and others have delay of average 1 day.
Table-II shows very high no. of hospitalization in the study area particularly in males. Since Hospitalization involves high expenditure and complete disturbance of family routine generally, women avoid getting admitted in hospitals. This may be true for the study area too.
Table-III also shows that for hospitalization, main source was public hospitals (18 out of 27). The most important reason for seeking treatment at public hospital was free and or inexpensive treatment. Trust hospitals and Private hospitals do have their share as per two factors namely closeness and good reputation in the community. 42% were taking treatment from the public hospitals, 38% from the private health providers and 10% were taking no treatment at all.
Three out of Five Tuberculosis patients were on Revised National Tuberculosis Control Program (RNTCP) while 2 were on treatment from private providers.
51% patients of chronic illnesses were found to be on irregular treatment and the major reasons were ignorance and affordability. Out of 7 Hypertension patients 4 were on irregular treatment while 1 out of 5 Tuberculosis patient were on irregular treatment.
Maternity related health-seeking behaviour
There were total 19 births in one year in the study area. Data for antenatal care and births were recorded from all. Four Antenatal women were also interviewed. Out of four, one was not registered. Average registration time was 4 months of amenorrhea. 81.8% were registered at the General Hospital and rest 18.2% were registered with the private Hospitals. Average no. of visit to the source was five. Only 50% of antenatal women registered with the Public hospital received free medicine. Tetanus Toxoid coverage was 100% for these women.
All deliveries were hospital deliveries. All births were also registered births. 88.9% deliveries took place at the General hospital. Average duration of stay was 4 days and average distance of source was 3 kilometers.
Conclusion
Study shows preference for private sector as source of treatment for acute episodes of illnesses for slum communities also. Out of total, 67% episodes of acute illness occurred among females. 76.6% of episodes were due to communicable diseases. Out of total episodes of hospitalization 33.3 % were due to surgical cases and 25.9% were due to infectious diseases. General Hospitals were main source of treatment for episodes of hospitalization. Irregularity of treatment was the important aspect of chronic illnesses. For maternity care also public sector hospitals were preferred by thecommunity.